Discourse 1891-06-23
LAST EDITION SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH, TUESDAY, . VOL 5. NO. 228.
HEADS OF THE CHURCH.
Interview with President Woodruff and
President Cannon on the Present
Political Situation in Utah
ABSOLUTE GOOD FAITH PREVAILS.
The Leaders of the Church, in Unequivocal Terms, Declare
That There is No Desire to Re-Estab-
lish Old Conditions.
Polygamy is a Dead Issue—The Church Will Not Attempt to Exer-
cise Any Control Over Its Members in Political Matters
—The Present Status of Affairs.
The only argument put forward in
opposition to the organization of par-
ties on national lines in Utah is that
people's party is not sincere in
the dissolution that has been effected
and that a plot has been laid by which
the liberals are to be divided and the
political control of Utah placed in the
hands of the mormon people for pur-
poses adverse to the interests of the
gentile element. It has been urged
that the movement, so far as the mor-
mons are concerned, is being engi-
neered by the church; and the demand
has been made that the heads of the
church should define their position in
connection with the subject before the
gentiles should be asked to believe that
the members of the organization are
sincere.
In brief, it has been claimed that it
is the purpose of the church to secure
statehood for Utah, and through the
alleged political control of its
members, seize all the offices
and carry on the government in
the interest of mormons and
against the interests of non-mormons.
It is held that the church claims the
right to exercise absolute authority
over its members in all matters and
that this extends to direct dictation as
to whom they should vote for at all
times. We are told that those who
have joined the democratic and repub-
lican parties have done so at the direc-
tion of the heads of the church, that the
people's party was dissolved at their
dictation, and that its members will be
subject at all times in the future to
their absolute control. We are told
further that polygamy has simply been
suspended, to be re-established in the
future under the protection of state
laws enacted by mormon legislatures;
and that these legislatures, elected by
the decree of the church, will pass
other laws intended to oppress gentiles
and work virtual confiscation of their
property.
There are thousands of earnest gen-
tiles who do not believe one word of
the charges of bad faith that are
put forward in connection with this
matter, but there are others who
are frightened by the pictures painted
before their imaginations and who are
honestly looking for further evidences
of good faith on the part of the mor-
mons before joining the present move-
ment. The entire controversy turns
upon this question of good faith, as was
shown by the organ of the extremists
when it declared in its issue of June
12th that it would yield to party di-
vision if any evidence could be adduced
that would be received in a court of
law that the dissolution of the people's
party was sincere.
THE TIMES has held that the evidence
of sincerity on the part of the mormons
is abundant and satisfactory, but it has
desired to satisfy all sincere doubters,
and for that reason it determined if
possible to secure expressions from
President Woodruff and President
George Q. Cannon upon the disputed
point. Such expressions have been se-
cured. They appear in connection
herewith and they must clear away the
last vestige of doubt from the mind of
every man who is willing to yield to
incontrovertible evidence.
It is not often that these highest dig-
nitaries of the church consent to under-
go the modern process of interviewing,
but when THE TIMES conveyed its de-
sire to them and represented the public
importance of the subject which it
wished to cover, they consented to re-
ceive its representative. When the lat-
ter called at church headquarters in
company with a gentleman who had
consented to introduce him, President
Cannon stepped into the reception
room to greet his visitors. The news-
paper man was invited to take a seat in
the office and state his business. Pres-
ident Woodruff was absent at that time,
but President Cannon suggested that
the points which it was desired to cover
might be put in the form of interroga-
tories which could be taken up and
answered in detail. This was done and
the questions which appear in the fol-
lowing interview were propounded. The
first counselor expressed his personal
opinion that there was no reason why
the queries could not all be answered
and undertook to lay them before pres-
ident Woodruff when that gentleman
should be able to again appear at the
office. The talk at the time ran on for
half an hour and THE TIMES represen-
tative was impressed by the manifest
earnestness and sincerity of President
Cannon. It was evident that he was
deeply interested in securing the estab-
lishment of conditions that would for-
ever remove his church from the con-
tentions of politics and that would
leave its people free to ally them-
selves with the national parti[es.]
He told the story of the agitation within
the church that led up to the renuncia-
tion of polygamy, and it was made ap-
parent that that renunciation could
not be otherwise than absolute and final.
President Cannon promised to have
the matter taken up at the earliest pos-
sible moment and to notify THE TIMES
when the answers to the questions
should be ready.
The queries were laid before Presi-
dent Woodruff and he and President
Cannon jointly give THE TIMES the
following as their deliberately expressed
views on every question touched upon:
"It was asserted that the people's party
was dissolved by direction of the
church. Is there any foundation for
that charge?"
"The people's party was dissoved, as
we understand, by the action of its
leading members. They have stated to
us their convictions that the time had
come for a division on national party
lines. There has been a growing feel-
ing in this direction for a long time,
and the dissolution of the people's party
is the result of that sentiment, and not
the fiat or instruction of the church. The
first intimation we had of dividing on
party lines came to us from Ogden.
There is, therefore, no foundation for
the charge that the church brought
about the dissolution of the people's
party."
"Does the church claim the right to
dictate to its members in political
matters?"
"The church does not claim any such
right."
"THE TIMES has held that the ap-
pearance of church management of the
people's party during recent times re-
sulted purely from the fact that the
party was composed almost entirely of
members of the church with prominent
churchmen taking part in its affairs,
and that there has not been church
rule as charged. Is this view correct?"
"THE TIMES has correctly stated the
facts connected with the appearance of
church management of the people's
party. That party having been com-
posed principally of members of the
church, and self defense having com-
pelled them to consult together and to
decided concerning the best steps to be
taken to preserve their rights, some
color has been given to the charge that
it was a church party. But this has not
been done in a church capacity. Men
have had influence in that party and
been listened to according to their ex-
perience, and not because of their
official position in the church."
"That being true, are we to under-
stand that the church will not assert
any right to control the poitical action
of its members in the future?"
"This is what we wish to convey and
have you understand. As officers of
the church we disclaim the right to
control the political actions of the mem-
bers of our body."
"Will there be any reson why mem-
bers of the church should come to-
gether and vote solidly, if political con-
ditions here are similar to those which
prevail elsewhere?"
"We cannot perceive any reason
why they should do this in the future,
if, as you say, political conditions should
exist here as they prevail elsewhere."
"Would leaders of the church counsel
the support of church members, irre-
spective of party affiliations?"
"It is not probable that the leaders
of the church would give any counsel
upon such subjects, and certainly
would not discriminate against equally
suitable men because they were not
members of the church. We would be
in favor of voting for suitable men,
regardless of their religious beliefs or
associations."
"Do you understand that those who
join the republican and democratic
parties will vote and work for gentile
candidates of those parties as freely
as for Mormon candidates?"
"This is clearly our understand-
ing, and we fully expect that former
members of the people's party who
join the two national parties will be
true to their party convictions and
sustain the nominees of their respec-
tive parties, though they may not be
members of the mormon church."
"Is it your intention to advise mem-
bers of the mormon church, when the
people's party members have divided
and after the liberal party has been
broken up, to unite in favor of the
mormon church and against the gen-
tiles? Do you know of any intention
or understanding on the part of the
heads of the church to advise the mem-
bers of the church, if statehood should
be obtained, to unite and co-operate in
respect to the interests of the church
against the gentiles?"
"We have refrained from interfering
in political matters because our posi-
tion, we ourselves not having a vote.
But we would consider it the height of
folly, even if we had a disposition to di-
rect the members of our church upon
political matters, to adivse them to
unite in favor of our church and against
the non-members thereof, if the present
politcal movement should continue.
We see no good reason, if the liberal
party should break up, for any such
division as has heretofore exited be-
tween mormons and non-mormons. We
have deplored the existence of this class
feeling, and believe it has been a fruit-
ful source of trouble. We shall hail
with unfeigned gratification the time
when the people of Utah, without re-
gard to their religious views, can unite
as citizens and labor for the advance-
ment and prosperity fo the territory.
If statehood should ever be obtained,
all the influence we could use to break
down the distinctions which have cre-
ated such bitterness in the past would
be exerted."
"Do you believe that if Utah should
be admitted as a state the mormons will
unite in electing members of the church
to the legislature, and that the legisla-
ture will make any laws favorable to the
mormons and unfavorable to the non-
mormons?"
"As we have already intimated, what-
ever influence we can use will be exert-
ed in favor of legislation that will be in
the interests and for the benefit of the
whole people. It would be most un-
fortunate if any attempt were made to
pass laws favorable to mormons and
unfavorable to non-mormons. Any
such attempt would be sure to bring
upon the mormon people evils which
they are desirious of averting. It is to
our interest to furnish no pretext for
the formation of an anti-mormon party,
which would no doubt be the result if
members of the church in the legisla-
ture were to attempt to discriminate by
legislation in favor of their co-religion-
ists."
"Is it your understanding that the
people's party has honestly and in good
faith dissolved, and that they will unite
with the democratic and republican
parties according to their convictions of
what is right?"
"This certainly is our understanding.
We can perceive no reason why the
representatives of the people's party
should have taken their recent action
unless it was their honest intention to
unite themselves with the national
parties."
"Do you know of any intention on
the part of the church or any of its offi-
cers or members every to organize a
political party with respect to the con-
ceived interests of the mormon
church?"
"We know of no such intention on
the part of anyone, and can see no ob-
ject to be attained, under the new con-
ditions which now surround us, by or-
ganizing any such party."
"Do you undersand that it is the
wish of the mormon church to maintain
a separation of church and state with
respect to all political quesions?"
"However much appearances may
have indicated that we have favored the
union of church and state, and not-
withstanding the many assertions which
have been made of this nature, there is
no real disposition among the people
of our church to unite church and state;
in fact, we believe there should be a
separation between the two. But in
past times the situation if this territory
was such that officers of the church
were frequently elected to civil office.
If the people availed themselves of the
best talent of the community they were
under the necessity very frequently of
selecting officers of the church to fill
these positions. You must understand
that nearly every reputable male
member of the mormon church holds
office in the church. Of course, where
the people, as was the case in many
localities, were all mormons, if they
elected any of their own members they
had to choose men who help position in
the church. Men were selected for
bishops because of their superior ability
to care and manage the affairs of
their wards. They were the practical and
experienced men of their several com-
munties, and in the estimation of the
people were suitable for legislators, etc.
Their election to civil offices led to the
idea that was a union of church
and state."
"Do you believe that it is the wish of
the mormon people to unite with the
great national parties and conduct
politics in this territory as they are
conducted in all other states?"
"That is the impression we have re-
ceived from conversation with men
among us who take the greatest inter-
est in political matters."
"Is there any reason why the mem-
bers of the church should not act freely
with the national parties at all times?"
"We know of no reason why they
should not."
"Would the leaders of the church,
under any circumstances, countenance
defiance of the laws against polygamy?"
"Speaking for ourselves, in view of
the experiences of the past, 'No, they
would not.' "
"Would leaders of the church, if
placed in official position, wink at vio-
lations of the anti-poly[g]amy laws?"
"We cannot say what others might
do, but for ourselves we say, 'We would
not wink at violations of the law.' "
"Would there be any desire among
church leaders to abolish the laws
against polygamy or to make them less
stringent if Utah were admitted to
statehood?"
"You may rest assured that church
leaders would neither attempt them-
selves, nor advise others to attempt, to
abolish those laws, if Utah were to be-
come a state."
"Is it your understanding that if a
member of the mormon church, since
the issuance of the manifesto [Official Declaraion 1] and its
adoption by the church, should enter
into polygamy he would thereby violate
the creed of the church, and would it
be wrong for him to do so?"
"We ought to state to you that we
have no creed. We have what are
called the articles of faith, among
which, however, there is nothing said
concerning polygamy. A member of
the church who should now enter into
that relation would violate the rule of
the church, and he would considered
a wrong-doer."
"Would you or any officer of the
church authorize a polygamous mar-
riage or countenance the practice of
unlawful cohabitation?"
"Again we have to say we can only
speak for ourselves, and say that we
would not authorize any such marriage
or practice violative of the law."
"Is it your understanding that the
mormon people are in good faith ob-
serving the laws of the United States
prohibiting polygamy and unlawful
cohabitation?"
"That is our understanding."
"Is there any foundation for the
charge that the mormon leaders are
now engaged in a political conspiracy
to secure political power for the
church?"
"There is not the least ground for
any such statement. We are not en-
gaged any conspiracy of this char-
acter."
"Is there anything to be gained for
the church by securing political control
in Utah with or without statehood?"
"We see nothing to be gained for the
church in this way."
"Is it not true that the member and
leaders of the church desire to place it
in a position in the community like that
occupied by other church societies?"
"The only protection the church de-
sires is that which it should obtain un-
der general laws which secure the rights
of all denominations. It would be most
unwise for the mormon people to en-
deavor to secure any advantage not
shared in by other religious people. All
that we ask is to have equal rights be-
fore the law."
"Is it your understanding that the
mormon people differ as to republi-
can and democratic parties, and that
they will act in accordance with their
convictions in uniting with those
parties?"
"That is our understanding."
"Is it your wish that the republican
and democratic parties should organize
and present their principle to the mor-
mon people, and that they should unite
with them according to their honest
convictions?"
"Personally we have felt that the
time would come when the two great
parties would be organized in this ter-
ritory, and we have felt that if an at-
tempt of this kind should be made, each
should have the fullest opportunity to
lay its principles before the people, so
that they might have a clear under-
standing of the issues and be able to
decide, in the light of facts presented
to them, to which of parties they
would belong."
"That being true, could anything be
gained by bad faith even if it should
be contemplated by any of the former
members of peoples' party?"
"Certainly not."
"The opponents of party division on
national lines declare that they want
evidence of the sincerity of the mormon
people. THE TIMES would ask you to
state whether the declaration of sin-
cerity on the part of those leaders who
have been before the public relfect your
views and meet with your approval."
"Those declarations express our
views and have our entire approval.
What greater evidence can be asked
than those which have already been
furnished? The statement has been
repeatedly made that the great objec-
tion to us was our belief and practice
of patriarchal marrige. In entire
good faith the manifesto was written,
signed by the leading men, and adopted
by one of the largest general confer-
ences of the church ever held—a con-
ference composed of about 15,000
people. It has been asserted, in addition,
that the people were governed by the
priesthood in political matters. This is
now disproved by the dissolution of the
people's party and the union of its
members with the two national parties.
What could possibly be gained by the
action of the people if they were not
sincere? If the elements of sincerity
were wanting, such a movement would
result in entire demoralization."