Letter from Benjamin Franklin Cummings Jr., 21 May 1894
To The First Presidency:
Dear Brethren: I trust that, in addressing this communication to
you, I am not intruding upon your valuable time with a matter which has no claim
thereto, as a sense of duty impels me to lay it before you.
In the year 1878, when I was in New England, gathering genealogies, I became
acquainted with W H Whitmore Esq, of Boston, who is probably the most accomplished
genealogist and herald in America. He informed me that he possessed an extensive
collection of books relating to American genealogy, which embraced a copy of
nearly every family genealogy that had ever been printed in this country. Know-
ing the inestimable value to Latter-day Saints of American lineage which would
attach to such a library, I asked Mr Whitmore if he would sell it. He relplied
positively that he would not sell it at any price, and stated that it was his
intention to some time bestow it as a gift upon some public library or institution.
Nearly two years ago, while I was in Boston, collecting genealogical records,
I again met Mr Whitmore, and conversed with him in regard to his collection of
genealogical books. He informed me that it embraced nearly every family genealogy
that had issues from the American press up to a few years ago, since which time
he had not, however, taken such pains to keep it complete. He thought that most
of the volumes he lacked could readily be onbtained, but that a large number that
were embraced in his collection could not be duplicated at any price. I again asked
him if he would be willing to sell his collectiion, and he replied in the negative,
saying that he had a son approaching maturity to whom he intented to leave it, pro-
vided the son would interest himself in it; otherwise he would give it to some
public institution.
A few days since I received a letter from Mr Whitmore, stating that he had had
a fire, which had impressed upon him the risk of such property, and he intimates
his willingness to sell the collection in a lot. He says that many of the books
were damaged by smoke, but not by water, and that re-binding will be necessary in
many cases, though I infer that few or none of the books were ruined for practical
use. He states that the appraised value was $9,500, which I suppose is the appraise-
ment of the insurance adjusters. He does not name the price at which he would sell,
probably deeming it best to leave that open for the present.
Nearly one thousand New England families have had their genealogies compiled and
printed in book or pamphlet form, and I understand that Mr Whitmore's collection
embraces a copy of nearly every one, except a portion of those published within
the last few years. I also understand that it includes a large number of town his-
tories, and works of like character, containing genealogical material. I have only
a partial understanding of the character of the library, and am not able to speak
of it from personal knowledge, as I never saw it, though Mr Whitmore kindly invited